← All Jobs
Posted Apr 4, 2026

**Experienced Personal Lines Customer Service Representative – Insurance – Base Salary to 60k/year – Garden City, NY**

Apply Now ✨
At arenaflex, we're on a mission to revolutionize the insurance industry by providing exceptional customer service and innovative solutions. As a Personal Lines Customer Service Representative, you'll play a vital role in delivering top-notch experiences to our clients, helping them navigate the complexities of homeowner and auto insurance. If you're passionate about building strong relationships, have a knack for problem-solving, and thrive in a fast-paced environment, we want to hear from you! **About arenaflex** arenaflex is a dynamic and forward-thinking organization that's dedicated to making a positive impact in the lives of our clients and employees. We're a family-owned insurance agency with a rich history on Long Island, and we're committed to providing personalized service, expert advice, and cutting-edge solutions to our customers. Our team is passionate about building strong relationships, and we're looking for like-minded individuals to join our ranks. **Responsibilities** As a Personal Lines Customer Service Representative, you'll be responsible for delivering exceptional customer service to our clients, ensuring their needs are met, and exceeding their expectations. Your duties will include: * Ensuring quality customer service on Homeowner and Auto policies, as well as a small amount of umbrella, motorcycle, boat, and other specialty policies * Taking calls, answering client questions, and cross-selling home and auto business * Shopping renewals, ID cards, proof of insurance, and other policy-related tasks * Managing a book of approximately 60 customers, providing personalized attention and support * Collaborating with our team to resolve complex issues and provide innovative solutions **Qualifications** To succeed in this role, you'll need: * 2+ years of experience in customer service, preferably in an independent agency * Property and Casualty (P&C) licensed in NY * Ability to commute to Garden City, NY or reliably work in a remote capacity * Experience with EZLynx preferred but not required * Strong communication and interpersonal skills * Ability to work in a fast-paced environment and prioritize multiple tasks * Passion for building strong relationships and delivering exceptional customer service **Compensation and Benefits** We offer a competitive compensation package, including: * Base salary up to 60k/year * Opportunities for career growth and professional development * Comprehensive benefits package, including medical, dental, and vision insurance * Generous paid time off and holidays * Access to cutting-edge technology and tools * Collaborative and dynamic work environment **Career Growth Opportunities** At arenaflex, we're committed to helping our employees grow and develop their careers. We offer: * Opportunities for professional development and training * Mentorship and coaching from experienced colleagues * Career advancement opportunities within the company * Flexible work arrangements and remote work options * Recognition and rewards for outstanding performance **Work Environment and Company Culture** Our office is located in Garden City, NY, and we offer a collaborative and dynamic work environment. We're a family-owned business with a rich history, and we're committed to building strong relationships with our clients and employees. Our culture is built on: * Respect and empathy for our clients and colleagues * Open communication and transparency * Continuous learning and professional development * Innovation and creativity * Teamwork and collaboration **How to Apply** If you're passionate about delivering exceptional customer service, have a knack for problem-solving, and thrive in a fast-paced environment, we want to hear from you! Please submit your application, including your resume and a cover letter, to [insert contact information]. We can't wait to hear from you and learn more about your qualifications and experience!